AEAmir Elshimi Book a call
Home / Blog / Due diligence

A number that doesn't trace back to a source isn't a number yet

Due diligenceJun 2026·1 min read
Due Diligence · Document Review

On a sell-side due diligence engagement for a Saudi industrial manufacturer, the company's pitch materials contained two different valuation figures across two documents. Neither was wrong on its own terms; they were calculated using different methodologies and different assumption sets. But they'd never been reconciled, and nobody had written down which one the company actually stood behind.

This is more common than it should be, and it's almost never intentional. Models get updated, decks don't. A consultant updates an assumption in a spreadsheet in November; the slide built in September uses the old number; both documents go to investors in December.

The fix isn't more sophisticated modeling. It's a simple discipline: every number in any client-facing document should trace back to a single, identified source: a specific cell in a specific file, with a specific version date. If the team can't answer "where does this come from?" immediately, the number isn't ready.

The earlier in the process you check this, the cheaper it is to fix. Catching it in internal review costs nothing. Catching it when a counterparty's analyst asks about it in a due diligence call costs credibility, which is harder to rebuild than any financial model.

Written by Amir ElshimiAll postsBook a call

Hiring, raising, or need a model that actually holds up under questioning?

Available for advisory mandates, buy-side and sell-side engagements, investor deck work, and senior analytical roles across Egypt and the Gulf.

WhatsApp Book a call