AEAmir Elshimi Book a call
Home / Blog / Valuation

Diagnose before you prescribe: why the working assumption is usually wrong

ValuationMay 2026·1 min read
Turnarounds · Financial Diagnosis

A Saudi trading and retail company had lost 59% of its equity value across seven years of audited financials. The explanation offered internally, and repeated externally, was demand: the consumer environment had weakened and the business was facing structural headwinds it couldn't control.

This was wrong. When I decomposed the P&L line by line across all seven years without starting from any conclusion, the picture was different: gross margins were stable. Revenue, while not growing fast, hadn't collapsed. The actual driver of the equity erosion was G&A cost inflation: overhead that had grown faster than the business, compounding quietly every year while the revenue line held.

A demand problem gets fixed with pricing strategy, sales investment and repositioning. A cost problem gets fixed by cutting overhead. Apply the demand remedy to a cost problem and you spend money you don't have trying to grow revenue that isn't the issue, while the actual problem keeps compounding underneath you.

Most turnaround situations have a working diagnosis already in the room when the conversation starts. The first job, before recommending anything, is to check whether the diagnosis is actually right. The value of outside analysis is precisely that it starts without the anchor.

Written by Amir ElshimiAll postsBook a call

Hiring, raising, or need a model that actually holds up under questioning?

Available for advisory mandates, buy-side and sell-side engagements, investor deck work, and senior analytical roles across Egypt and the Gulf.

WhatsApp Book a call