AEAmir Elshimi Book a call
Home / Blog / IC memos

Why most IC memos lead with the number they want you to believe

IC memosJun 2026·1 min read
Investment Memos · IC Process

The fastest way to lose a room of experienced investors is to show them only the best-case scenario. Most investment committee memos I've reviewed (including early drafts of my own) lead with the headline IRR or the NPV that makes the deal look most attractive, and bury the conservative-case numbers in an appendix that nobody opens before the meeting.

On a greenfield catering investment in Saudi Arabia, the scenario range I built ran from a 7-month payback at 67.9% IRR in the upside case to a substantially longer payback at a more moderate return in the conservative case. The temptation, always, is to lead with the number that makes someone want to invest. The document that actually earns trust leads with the case that's hardest to defend, then shows why the upside is plausible on top of it, not instead of it.

A committee that feels it's being sold the best case stops trusting the other numbers in the document. Once a reader suspects the memo was assembled to support a conclusion rather than to reach one, everything in it becomes suspect. One that sees the downside modeled with the same seriousness as the upside reads the whole document as analysis rather than advocacy.

The practical implication: lead with the scenario that would kill the deal if it happened. If the answer to "what has to go wrong for this not to work?" is answered clearly and early, the rest of the memo gets read as credible.

Written by Amir ElshimiAll postsBook a call

Hiring, raising, or need a model that actually holds up under questioning?

Available for advisory mandates, buy-side and sell-side engagements, investor deck work, and senior analytical roles across Egypt and the Gulf.

WhatsApp Book a call